Fellow Opus 2 vs Baratza Encore ESP

• You rotate beans weekly or brew both espresso and filter: Opus 2. Near-zero retention is the spec that matters to you, and the stepless dial lands exactly where you want.
• One bag at a time, espresso only, learning to dial in: Encore ESP. Numbers you can record beat a knob you have to re-learn.
• You expect to keep the grinder for a decade: Encore ESP. Baratza publishes burrs, gearbox parts and the ring as user-replaceable.
• You single dose from small bags of specialty coffee:Opus 2 — it ships a 100 g catch cup and a 30 g dosing cup that fits both 54mm and 58mm baskets.

Prices shown are from Amazon as of October 18, 2026 and change often — the button always goes to the current listing. Some links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

A steppedgrinder moves in defined clicks. Its advantage is memory: setting 9 is setting 9 forever, so you can record a recipe, hand the grinder to someone else, and come back to the same shot after a month on a different bean. Its limitation is granularity — when the grind you want sits between two clicks, you cannot have it, and the usual workaround is to change the dose instead.

A stepless grinder turns continuously, so the grind itself is always the adjustment. Nothing is out of reach. The cost is that there is no number to write down: you are navigating by feel and by shot time, and if you knock the dial you have lost your place.

For espresso specifically, stepless is the more capable mechanism and numbered is the moreteachable one. That is why our recommendation splits on experience as much as on habit: if you have never dialed in a shot before, numbers shorten the learning curve considerably. Our sour shot and bitter shotguides are the diagnostic half of that process, and both assume you can reproduce yesterday's grind to compare against.

Who it is for: the drinker who buys small bags of good coffee, changes them often, and wants the grinder to give back exactly what was weighed in.

The Opus 2 is Fellow's second pass at an all-purpose grinder and it reads like a single-dose machine wearing a small hopper. 48mm hardened stainless burrs, a stepless adjustment dial, and what Fellow describes as near-zero retention technology — the specification that matters if you rotate between a light roast for filter and a darker one for espresso. In the box are a 100 g catch cup and a 30 g dosing cup that fits 54mm and 58mm portafilters, so it doses into a basket as readily as into a brewer.

What we like: stepless adjustment at a price where stepped is normal, near-zero retention so one bean does not contaminate the next, a dosing cup that fits both common basket sizes, and a footprint narrow enough to sit beside a compact machine. The honest cons: Fellow positions this as an all-purpose grinder rather than a dedicated espresso grinder, and 48mm conical burrs at the fine end are working harder than a 50mm flat set does — it will dial a shot in, but it is not the grinder for someone chasing the last five percent. Stepless means no numbers to return to. The 100 g capacity is a feature if you single dose and a nuisance if you want to fill a hopper and forget it. And it is a current-generation product with a shorter track record than the Baratza mechanism.

Who it is for: the buyer whose first espresso machine arrives this week, who wants to be dialing in on day one rather than learning a mechanism.

The Encore ESP is Baratza's espresso rework of the long-running Encore. It uses 40mm M2 conical burrs and a recalibrated dial that spends settings 1–20 on espresso at roughly 20 microns per step and settings 21–40 on filter at roughly 90 microns per step. Half the dial sits in the band where espresso actually lives, which is the opposite of how most dual-purpose grinders are laid out. It ships a 54mm dosing cup and a 58mm portafilter adapter, and Baratza's engineering premise is repair: burrs, gearbox parts and the ring are user-replaceable through their US channel.

What we like: numbered settings you can write down and return to, espresso steps small enough to dial a shot in, a genuine filter range on the upper half of the dial, and a repair path rather than a landfill date. The honest cons: 40mm conical burrs are the smallest electric set at this price, so it grinds slowly and with a wider particle spread. It is stepped, so you will occasionally want a setting between two clicks. It is hopper-fed with real retention, so switching beans means purging. And there is no timer, display or dose automation at all.

Our Encore ESP review has the long-term case, and Encore ESP vs Breville Smart Grinder Pro covers the other grinder people weigh it against at this price.

Retention is how much ground coffee stays inside the grinder after a dose — in the chute, around the burrs, in the exit path. On a hopper-fed grinder it is normal and mostly harmless if you drink one coffee: today's retained grounds come out in tomorrow's dose of the same bean, so the only cost is a few grams of staleness.

It becomes a real problem the moment you keep two bags open. Switch from a dark espresso blend to a light filter roast and the first several grams out of the grinder are the previous bean. The fix on a high-retention grinder is to purge — run a few grams through and throw them away — which costs coffee and patience every single time you switch.

The Opus 2 is designed to make that unnecessary, and that single property is why it suits a different buyer than the ESP rather than simply being better or worse. If you want to understand the category the Opus 2 borrows from, our single-dose grinder guide covers grinders built entirely around this idea.

Bigger burrs cut more coffee per rotation and generally produce a tighter particle distribution at the same setting, which is why burr diameter gets quoted so often. The Opus 2's 48mm hardened stainless set is physically larger than the ESP's 40mm M2 conical set, and on paper that favors the Fellow.

Two caveats keep that from being decisive. First, both are conicalburrs, and the step change in espresso grind quality comes with flat burrs of 50mm and up — our flat vs conical burr guide explains the geometry, and the Eureka Mignon Notte is the cheapest 50mm flat grinder we recommend. Second, neither maker publishes a particle-distribution figure, so the difference between these two specific burr sets is something we describe from geometry rather than claim from a test we did not run. Units tested in-house: zero.

Who it is for: one or two shots a day, a buyer who wants the finest adjustment money can buy at this price, and no objection to a minute of cranking.

Worth naming because it resolves the trade-off above rather than splitting it. The J-Ultra has a 48mm titanium-coated stainless conical burr and an external adjustment ring giving 100 clicks per rotation at 8 microns per click, across five rotations for 500 clicks of range. That is numbered and finer than either electric here, with near-zero retention by design, because a hand grinder spends its whole budget on burrs and adjustment instead of a motor and housing.

The honest con is the obvious one: espresso-fine grinding is the hardest work a hand grinder does, so budget the better part of a minute of cranking per double, every morning. Our best hand grinders guide covers the field, and J-Ultra vs Comandante C40 MK4 is the head-to-head at the top of it.

• Two or more bags open at a time? Fellow Opus 2. Retention is your problem and it is the one this grinder was designed to solve.
• First espresso machine, learning to dial in? Baratza Encore ESP. Numbered settings turn dialing in from guesswork into bookkeeping.
• Want it to last ten years? Encore ESP, on the published repair path.
• Single dosing small specialty bags? Opus 2, and read our single-dose guide before you commit.
• Want the finest adjustment at this price and will crank? 1Zpresso J-Ultra.

If neither fits, the next bracket up changes the answer: a 50mm flat-burr stepless grinder removes both compromises at once. Our best espresso grinder under $300 ranks that field, and best grinders for espresso is the wider shortlist.