Baratza Encore ESP vs Breville Smart Grinder Pro

• Espresso is the main job? Encore ESP. Twenty dedicated espresso steps beat a dial that also has to cover French press.
• You own a Breville machine and want the path of least resistance? Smart Grinder Pro. It doses into a 54mm Breville basket without a funnel, and our best grinder for a Breville guide puts it in that context.
• You grind for espresso and filter in the same week?Encore ESP — settings 21–40 are its filter range, at roughly 90 microns per step.
• You want to stop guessing entirely? Neither. Save for a stepless grinder; the Eureka Mignon Notte is the first one worth the jump.

Both grinders currently sit at the same list price, which is exactly why the question keeps coming up:

Prices shown are from Amazon as of October 17, 2026 and change often — the button always goes to the current listing. Some links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

Espresso is the one brewing method where grind adjustment has to be fine-grained, because the puck is the restriction. Move the grind a little coarser and the shot runs fast and tastes thin; a little finer and it chokes. The range you are working inside is narrow, so what matters is not how many settings a grinder has in total but how many of them land in that band.

Baratza's answer is to split the dial in half. Settings 1–20 are espresso at roughly 20 microns per step; settings 21–40 are filter at roughly 90 microns per step. You get twenty espresso positions and they are numbered, so a recipe that worked is a number you can write down.

Breville's answer is to spread 60 settings across the whole span from espresso to French press. That is a genuinely wider range — the Smart Grinder Pro reaches coarser than the ESP does — and it is the more versatile dial on paper. The cost is that the espresso portion of 60 shared settings has fewer steps in it than the ESP's dedicated twenty. Breville does not publish a micron figure per step, so we are describing the structure rather than quoting a number they have not given.

Who it is for: the buyer whose first espresso machine is arriving, who wants to spend the first week adjusting shots rather than fighting a mechanism.

The ESP is Baratza's espresso rework of the long-running Encore, and the changes are the ones that matter rather than cosmetic. 40mm M2 conical burrs, the recalibrated half-espresso dial described above, and a 54mm dosing cup plus a 58mm portafilter adapter in the box so the grounds reach the basket whichever size your machine uses. The motor is a gear-reduced DC unit at roughly 550 RPM and 70 W, which keeps grounds cool and the grinder quiet relative to high-speed units.

What we like: numbered settings you can return to exactly, espresso steps small enough to dial a shot rather than approximate it, a real filter range on the top half of the dial, and a repair path instead of a disposal date. The honest cons: 40mm conical burrs are the smallest electric set in this price bracket, so it grinds slowly and with a wider particle spread than a 50mm flat set. It is stepped, so the between-two-clicks problem applies. It is hopper-fed with real retention. And there is no timer, no display and no dosing automation of any kind — you weigh, every time.

Our full Encore ESP review covers the ownership case, and Encore vs Encore ESP explains why the cheaper non-ESP Encore is the wrong buy for espresso.

Who it is for: a Breville machine owner, or anyone who wants a repeatable timed dose delivered into the basket with no cup, no funnel and no tipping.

The Smart Grinder Pro is the more convenient grinder here by a clear margin, and the convenience is almost entirely about dosing. Breville publishes 60 grind settings from espresso to French press, stainless steel conical burrs, an LCD showing setting, grind time and shot count, and a dose timer adjustable in 0.2-second increments. It ships with cradles for both small 50–54mm and large 58mm portafilters plus an airtight container and a filter-basket adapter, so one machine doses espresso into a basket and filter coffee into a cone without buying an accessory.

What we like: the dose timer is repeatable once set, both portafilter cradles are included, the LCD removes second-counting, and it is the easier grinder to live with on a rushed morning. The honest cons: 60 settings covering espresso andFrench press means the espresso portion of the dial has fewer usable positions than the ESP's dedicated twenty, so this is the grinder more likely to leave you stranded between settings. Breville does not publish a burr diameter, which we flag rather than fill in. A timed dose is a volumetric dose, so it drifts as beans age and as the hopper empties — weigh the output, do not trust the timer. And it is hopper-fed with real retention, so it suits one bean at a time rather than rotating bags.

This is where the two grinders diverge most in daily use, and the honest answer is that the convenience is partly an illusion. A dose timer measures time, and what you need is mass. Beans get drier and less dense as they age, retention changes what comes out, and a hopper that is nearly empty feeds differently from a full one. So a timer that gave you 18 g last week may give you 17.2 g this week at the same setting.

That does not make the timer useless — it gets you close with one button and no dosing cup to wash, which is real. It does mean a scale is not optional on either grinder. Our coffee scale guide covers the 0.1 g scales that fit under a portafilter, and do I need a scale for espresso answers the question directly. The dose you are aiming for is in how many grams for a double shot.

Both grinders are hopper-fed with meaningful retention, which matters if you keep two bags open. Grounds left in the chute and burr chamber from yesterday's bean come out in today's dose, so switching roasts means purging a few grams first. Neither of these is the grinder for someone who rotates a light filter roast and a dark espresso blend in the same week.

If that describes you, the category to look at is single dosing instead — grinders designed to give back almost exactly what you weighed in. Our single-dose grinder guide covers that field, and Fellow Opus 2 vs Encore ESP pits a near-zero-retention design against the ESP at the same money.

Baratza's whole engineering premise is repair: burrs, gearbox parts and the adjustment ring are user-replaceable through their US channel, and a grinder you can re-burr is a cheaper decade than one you replace. Breville does not publish the Smart Grinder Pro's burrs as a user-serviceable part, which is not the same as saying it cannot be serviced — it means we will not claim a repair path the manufacturer has not documented.

Either way, burrs dull and chutes clog, and the maintenance interval is shorter than most owners expect. Our grinder cleaning guideworks through the routine on Baratza's own published schedule.

Who it is for: the buyer who has read the paragraph about being stuck between two clicks and decided not to live with it.

The Notte is the cheapest grinder Eureka sells and it solves the single limitation both grinders above share. 50mm flat steel burrs — the largest in this bracket — and a stepless micrometric knob that turns continuously, so the grind itself becomes the adjustment instead of something you work around. It dispenses into the portafilter directly, with a metal case hand-assembled in Italy.

The honest cons: it costs more than either grinder above, there is no display, no timer and no programmable dosing at all, and stepless means no numbers to write down — you learn the knob by feel. Our Mignon Notte review has the full case, and best espresso grinder under $300 ranks it against this bracket.

• Espresso first, filter sometimes: Encore ESP. The dial is built for exactly that split.
• Breville machine, 54mm basket, rushed mornings: Smart Grinder Pro. It doses into your basket out of the box.
• French press or drip is your main brew and espresso is occasional:Smart Grinder Pro — its coarse end goes further.
• You want to stop compromising: Mignon Notte, and buy the machine later if you must. The best grinders for espresso guide explains why the grinder is the higher-leverage purchase.

One thing neither grinder changes: a pressurized portafilter sets its own resistance through a restrictor hole, so if your machine has one, grind precision buys you much less than it would otherwise. Check which basket you have before spending $200 on resolution you cannot use.